2023-2024: Building Materials Evaluation Commission Annual Report

Letter to the Minister

June 6, 2024

The Honourable Paul Calandra
Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing
777 Bay Street, 17th Floor
Toronto, Ontario M7A 2J3

Dear Minister Calandra:

Re: Building Materials Evaluation Commission

Annual Report - Fiscal year 2023-2024

It is my pleasure, as Chair of the Building Materials Evaluation Commission, to present to you the Building Materials Evaluation Commission’s Annual Report for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2024.

The enclosed Annual Report highlights the Building Materials Evaluation Commission’s accomplishments over the 2023-2024 fiscal year and outlines challenges that have been identified for the future. In total, the Building Materials Evaluation Commission received nine new applications, issued nine new authorizations, and three applications are under review.

I would like to thank my fellow Commission members whose knowledge and dedication have earned the Building Materials Evaluation Commission an excellent reputation as a valuable service provider in the building and construction industry. On behalf of all members of the Building Materials Evaluation Commission, I would like to express our thanks to the staff of the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing for their support to the Building Materials Evaluation Commission. Without their excellent administrative, technical, secretariat, operational and legal assistance the Building Materials Evaluation Commission simply could not function.

Sincerely,

Leo Grellette
Chair, Building Materials Evaluation Commission

Mandate

The Building Materials Evaluation Commission (the “Commission”) is an independent regulatory agency whose legislative authority is set out in Section 28 of the Building Code Act, 1992.

The Commission has a mandate to evaluate and authorize for use in Ontario, innovative construction materials, systems or building designs not currently recognized by the Building Code. In doing so, the Commission has the power to conduct, or cause to be conducted, research, analysis and evaluation of such innovative materials, systems and building designs. The Commission is not a testing body but may require that testing be carried out by an applicant as part of its evaluation.

Commitment to service and guiding principles

The inaugural meeting of the Commission was held on February 18, 1976 and was made possible by the Legislature passing the first Building Code Act in 1974. Since then, the Commission has endeavoured to provide a timely, expert, and transparent process for authorizing the use of innovative materials, systems and building designs. In doing so, the Commission has earned a reputation of being an effective, useful and quality service provider within the construction industry.

The Commission has signed a Memorandum of Understanding with the Minister relating to the exercise of its mandate. The Memorandum of Understanding sets out the relationship between the Commission Chair and the Minister and the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing with respect to the Commission and the services it provides. The purpose of the Memorandum of Understanding is to establish the responsibilities of these parties and to ensure that accountability is a fundamental principle observed in the management, administration and operation of the Commission. The Memorandum of Understanding was updated in February 2024.

As an agency of government, the Commission conducts itself according to the management principles of the Government of Ontario. The Commission’s proceedings are governed by the Building Code Act, 1992, the Building Materials Evaluation Commission’s Guidelines, Policies and Procedures Handbook, and Management Board of Cabinet directives. These principles and governance elements include ethical behaviour, accountability, excellence in management, using public resources efficiently and effectively, and high-quality service to the public, by contributing to the health, safety, accessibility and energy efficiency of buildings in Ontario and by playing a positive role within Ontario’s construction sector.

About the Building Materials Evaluation Commission

Building Materials Evaluation Commission process and procedure

Applications for authorization are submitted to the Commission by companies or individuals producing building materials, systems or designs.

While the Commission as a whole makes decisions on applications, subcommittees are usually established to carry out detailed evaluations and report to the Commission. The subcommittees typically consist of Commission members who are familiar with, and/or have expertise in, the field of technology associated with the application. The Commission may request comments from the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing’s technical staff or other research or standards issuing bodies.

Generally, the Commission holds one general meeting each month, with an average of three subcommittee meetings per application. The issuance of decisions by the Commission usually takes between 90 and 120 days, depending on the complexity of the application and if any additional information is required of the applicants, as well as the timeliness of their response(s).

Commission members and ministry staff

As of March 31, 2024, the Commission had 8 part-time members, which includes the Chair. The Vice-Chair position is currently vacant. All members are appointed by Order in Council (OIC). Current Management Board of Cabinet Directives permit individuals appointed to the Commission to serve a combined term of appointment of up to 10 years. Commission members attend monthly meetings and subcommittee meetings and make decisions on applications for authorizations. The Chair and Vice-Chair are also responsible for making administrative decisions regarding operations and relations with the Ministry.

The following divisions/branches of the Ministry and technology cluster support the Commission:

• Planning and Growth Division’s Building and Development Branch
• Business Management Division’s Corporate Services Branch, and Controllership and Financial Planning Branch
• Legal Services Branch
• Community Services Information and Information Technology Cluster.

The Commission receives all of its staffing and financial resources from the Building and Development Branch of the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing (the “Ministry”).

The direct support staff assigned by the Ministry to the Commission consists of a 0.8 Full Time Equivalent (FTE) for the Commission Secretary. The Secretary is responsible for the overall administration of the Commission. This involves managing the appointments process, issues management, business planning, performance measurements, monitoring of expenditures, and ensuring compliance with agency sector requirements and Management Board of Cabinet directives.

The Commission works towards staggering the terms of appointment for the Commission so that Orders in Council expire in small groups. This will allow for newly appointed members to be mentored by experienced members and will support knowledge maintenance within the Commission.

In addition to ensuring an adequate number of members, the Commission must also continue to work at maintaining the knowledge base of its membership, so it is important for the Commission to continue to solicit new members with expertise that reflects a full spectrum of relevant technical disciplines (for example plumbing, mechanical systems, on-site sewage systems, etc.). As described in the Memorandum of Understanding, the role of the Chair includes keeping the Minister informed of upcoming appointment vacancies and providing recommendations for appointments and/or reappointments to the Commission.

The following is a summary of the appointments for the 2023-2024 fiscal year:

• One member’s OIC expired on March 4, 2024
• The Chair’s OIC expired on March 31, 2024

The Chair and member are expected to be reappointed for a three-year term in the 2024-2025 fiscal year.

Caseload

In 2023-2024, the Building Materials Evaluation Commission received nine new applications, issued nine new authorizations, and three applications are under review. The Commission notes that the increase in the number of applications received over the last few fiscal years may be the result of the expiration policy (as of 2018, authorizations now expire every five years) and the industry desire to bring new and innovative products to Ontario.

In addition to new applications, the Commission considers requests for substantive and/or technical amendments to existing authorizations and reviews its existing authorizations for possible revocation. Applications for amendment are processed in the same manner as a new application. The Commission reviews and evaluates the details of the proposed amendment as innovative products, systems and designs are modified and updated. The process for review and revocation adds to the workload of the Commission.

In 2008 the Commission launched an initiative to manage and keep current all existing authorizations including the decision to make all existing (and future) authorizations expire after a set time period. As necessary, the Commission will continue to review authorizations with the release of each new Building Code.

Analysis of Building Materials Evaluation Commission performance

Performance measures and targets

The Commission has long-standing established performance measures and targets.

These are:

• fairness
• timeliness
• quality and consistency
• transparency
• expertise
• courtesy

The results of the Commission’s performance can be found in Appendix 1.

Several steps have been taken to enhance the Commission’s performance and accountability over the past several years, including continued monitoring of Commission-specific performance measures.

Once an application has been processed by the Commission, all applicants that utilize Commission services in the 2023-2024 fiscal year were asked to complete a survey to provide feedback on the Commission’s performance. The following is a summary of how the Building Materials Evaluation Commission fared on its targets for its goals in 2023-2024:

Fairness

• The stated target of not more than 10% of decisions should result in judicial review on an annual basis was again met in the 2023-2024 fiscal year. No judicial reviews were received.
• Survey results of the parties that utilized Commission services in the 2023-2024 fiscal year indicate that 100% of respondents agreed that they were treated fairly.

Timeliness

• The Commission aims to make a decision within an average of 120 days of the initial consideration of an application. Records from the 2023-2024 fiscal year indicate that the Commission met this target and made on average decisions within 120 days.

Quality and Consistency

• Survey results indicated that 100% of respondents felt that the processes and procedures had a high degree of quality and consistency.

Transparency

• Survey results indicated that 100% of respondents felt that the processes and procedures were clear and understandable.

Expertise

• Survey results indicated that 100% of respondents felt that members demonstrated an appropriate level of expertise regarding the technical matters under consideration.

Courtesy

• Survey results indicated that 100% of respondents felt that they were treated with courtesy by Ministry staff and Commission members.

These performance measures were adopted as a result of the recommendations established in 2000 by the Agency Reform (Guzzo) Commission.

Strategic direction

The Commission’s strategic direction is consistent with its mandate as well as government priorities for the agency sector. As part of the government of Ontario, agencies are expected to act in the best interests of Ontarians by being efficient, effective, and providing value for money. In alignment with this expectation, the Commission’s direction and objectives are consistent with the following government priorities that were outlined in the BMEC's 2023-2026 Business Plan and are reflected in the work done during the 2023-2024 fiscal year:

Transparency and Accountability

• Abide by applicable government directives and policies and ensuring transparency and accountability in reporting.
• Adhere to accounting standards and practices, and responding to audit findings, where applicable.
• Identify appropriate skills, knowledge and experience needed to effectively support the board’s role in agency governance and accountability.

Risk Management

• Develop and implement an effective process for the identification, assessment, and mitigation of agency risks, including COVID-19 impacts and any future emergency risks.

Digital Delivery and Customer Service

• Explore and implement digitization for online service delivery to ensure customer service standards are met.
• Use a variety of approaches or tools to ensure service delivery in all situations, including pursuing delivery methods that have evolved since COVID-19.

Operational performance

The Commission believes that in order to provide quality service to the public and the construction sector in particular, the Commission, as an agency, must operate as effectively and efficiently as possible. This means more than having performance measures and strategic direction in place to strive for service excellence on a day-to-day basis. It also means pursuing excellence from an operational and administrative standpoint over the long term. To achieve this, the Commission also assesses itself on its operational performance. The following are some of the operational achievements from 2023-2024:

• The Commission continued to provide a cost effective and expeditious mechanism for the evaluation of innovative materials, systems and building designs.
• The Commission continued to deliver the same level of service by accepting electronic applications and held majority of their meetings remotely via telephone and video conferencing. The Commission only held one in-person meeting this fiscal year. These measures are in keeping with the government’s aforementioned priority to enhance digital delivery and customer service.
• The Commission continued its practice of surveying clients and received an overall satisfaction rating of 100% from clients who had used the services of the Commission between April 1, 2023 and March 31, 2024.
• The Commission continued to maintain its compliance with the Agencies and Appointments Directive (AAD) as follows:
  • Prepared, finalized and submitted the annual three-year Business Plan;
  • Completed its Annual Report for 2022-2023 fiscal year and approved within the specified time frame;
  • Publicly posted the Commission’s Memorandum of Understanding, Business Plan and Annual Report.
• The Commission Chair and Ministry staff worked with the Public Appointments Secretariat and the Minister’s Office to recommend new members, including a vice-chair to the Commission, as well as reappoint expired members.

Financial report

Budget

The Commission has no financial budget separate from that of the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. All costs, including Commission per diem remuneration, other operating costs and administrative support, are provided by the Ministry.

Revenues

Revenues in the form of application fees are recorded as part of the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing’s non-tax revenues. The current application fee for the Commission which became effective on January 1, 2018, is $11,000.

Remuneration of members

As part-time appointees, Commission members receive remuneration in the form of a per diem as established by the Management Board of Cabinet’s Agencies and Appointments Directive. Effective January 1, 2018, this per diem ranged from $472 for members to $583 for the Vice-Chair and $744 for the Chair. Commission members are also reimbursed for out-of-pocket expenses associated with attending Commission meetings in Toronto and elsewhere in the province, in accordance with Management Board of Cabinet’s Travel, Meal and Hospitality Expenses Directive. Costs associated with Commission activities, including member per diems and other operating costs, form part of the overall budget of the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. The list of the Commission members’ renumeration for fiscal year 2023-2024 can be found in Appendix 2.

The Building Materials Evaluation Commission’s application rate and/or complexity of issues directly impact the budget requirement in support of Commission activities.

Appendix 1 - performance measures table

Appendix 2 - Building Materials Evaluation Commission appointees list