Chapter 4 Notifications and response
4.1 Initial notification
4.1.1 According to responsibilities outlined in federal legislation, (see PNERP, Master Plan Paragraph 5.2.1) regulations and agreement with the provincial government, the Bruce Nuclear Generating Station (BNGS) operator shall notify the pre-designated contact points (see Paragraph 4.1.12 below) in provincial and municipal emergency organizations as soon as conditions arise at the facility which require such initial notification under the criteria described in Table 4.1 and, as incorporated in facility procedures.
4.1.2 The form and content of the initial notification shall be determined by the Commissioner of Emergency Management.
4.1.3 The BNGS operator shall make a notification to the designated provincial and municipal contact points within 15 minutes of categorizing the event.
4.1.4 The initial notification message from the BNGS operator shall include:
- the notification category
- recommended default protective measures
4.1.5 Where more than one criteria are applicable, the highest category triggered shall be reported in the notification. The notification message shall not be delayed to permit an accurate assessment of the applicable category.
4.1.6 In the case of a General Emergency or On-Site Emergency notification, the message must state whether an emission is ongoing or if not, give a best estimate of when it is expected to commence and the wind direction at the time of the notification.
4.1.7 During the initial stage (see Paragraph 4.1.8 below) of an emergency, the General Emergency notification category (received by the PEOC Duty Officer) initiates the implementation of off-site default protective measures.
4.1.8 The initial stage of an emergency is defined as the earlier of:
- The first 4 hours after the initial notification, or
- Once ongoing reporting by the BNGS EMC to the PEOC Scientific Section is established.
4.1.9 If during the initial stages of an emergency, the assessment of the on-site situation changes to warrant a different category (and to recommended protective measures) than those initially notified, then the BNGS operator shall immediately issue such changes to the designated provincial and municipal contact points.
4.1.10 Once ongoing reporting is established between the BNGS EMC and the PEOC Scientific Section, any changes to the notification category or recommended protective measures shall be included in the regular data transmittals sent by the BNGS EMC to the PEOC Scientific Section and shall no longer be transmitted to the provincial and municipal contact points.
4.1.11 The BNGS operator cannot terminate or cancel a notification once it has been made. Such a notification shall automatically lapse when the provincial response to it is formally terminated (see Paragraph 4.2.3 below).
- Contact points and phone numbers shall be pre-determined and routinely validated to ensure availability.
- The provincial contact point shall be the PEOC Duty Officer.
- The following municipal contact points shall be set out in the municipal plans:
- A contact point to receive an initial notification anytime, 24 hours per day, 7 days per week.
- A municipal emergency response staff person who can be contacted anytime 24 hours per day, 7 days per week for passage of information and monitoring of the situation following the initiation of a notification.
4.2 Initial provincial and municipal response
4.2.1 The initial provincial response to a notification from BNGS shall depend on the category (and other relevant information) contained in the notification message (see Table 4.1).
4.2.2 Within 15 minutes of the receipt of an initial notification, the PEOC Commander shall decide on the initial response level to be adopted and inform the municipal contact point(s). This level should normally be the one linked to the category of the notification received (see Table 4.2) unless another level is judged to be more appropriate.
4.2.3 The PEOC Commander or PEOC Operations Chief may adopt another provincial response level as appropriate including termination of the provincial response. All stakeholders shall be notified of any such change.
4.2.4 The initial (and any subsequent) response level to be adopted by the Municipalities and other organizations shall be communicated by the PEOC Commander (see Paragraph 4.2.2 above) to all stakeholders. The general municipal response for each level is outlined in Table 4.2; the specific response shall be described in the municipal plans.
4.3 Internal notifications
4.3.1 Each organization or agency required to respond to a nuclear emergency shall have an internal notification system to inform all concerned staff of the imminence or occurrence of an emergency under this plan, and of the appropriate response to the notification.
4.3.2 Each jurisdiction and organization receiving a notification of an activation response (either partial or full) shall issue an appropriate internal notification to its units and individuals who are required to respond. The notification shall indicate the level of activation to be adopted.
4.3.3 The PEOC and each jurisdiction and organization required to respond and issue an internal or external notification (see Section 4.4 below) shall prepare a notification procedure and list of recipients.
4.3.4 PEOC notifications
- If the PEOC is to be activated (whether fully or partially), then the PEOC Commander shall issue an appropriate notification (including an indication of the level of activation) to at least one pre-designated contact point in each of the following jurisdictions and organizations:
- Municipality of Kincardine
- each provincial-level organization required to respond to the emergency
- Host Municipalities
- Bruce Nuclear Generating Station
- Additionally, the PEOC Commander shall notify:
- PEOC staff
- Emergency Information Section staff
4.4 External notifications
4.4.1 Additional organizations or agencies which might be affected by a nuclear emergency under this plan, or which may be required to assist in responding to it, should be notified at an appropriate stage by their links in the Emergency Response Organization. As such, upon adoption of an activation response (partial or full), external notifications shall be carried out as detailed below. The notification must indicate the level of activation being adopted.
4.4.2 The PEOC Commander shall ensure the following are notified:
- the federal Government Operations Centre (GOC) and the Federal Nuclear Emergency Plan (FNEP) Duty Officer who shall then complete the notifications listed in Section 4.4.3 below
- the Province of Quebec (Sûreté du Quebec)
- the State of New York Emergency Management Agency
- the State of Ohio Emergency Management Agency
- the State of Michigan Emergency Management Agency
- Canada News Wire/National Alert Aggregation and Dissemination System (NAADS)
- Bell Canada
- wireless phone providers
4.4.3 As directed by the FNEP Duty Officer, the federal Government Operations Centre (GOC) shall notify:
- Natural Resources Canada (NRCan)
- Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP)
- Privy Council Office (PCO)
- Transport Canada
- Department of National Defence (DND)
- Canadian Coast Guard (which shall notify the US Coast Guard under agreed protocols)
- CNSC Duty Officer
- Global Affairs Canada
- Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA)
- Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA)
- Indigenous Services Canada (ISC)
- Air Traffic Control
- CN Rail
- CP Rail
- U.S. Department of Homeland Security
- international organizations under existing agreements, conventions and departmental emergency plans
4.4.4 Other agencies and organizations shall be notified by the following:
- Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs shall notify the Dairy Farmers of Ontario.
- Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services shall notify the Red Cross, Ontario Zone.
- Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry shall notify:
- Central Lake Ontario Conservation Authority
- Toronto and Region Conservation Authority
- Municipal plans shall include provisions for the following external notifications:
- Bruce County
- Town of Saugeen Shores
- Bluewater Board of Education
- Grey-Bruce County Catholic District School Board
- paramedic services
- Inverhuron Provincial Park
- Brucedale Conservation Area
- Bruce Municipal Telephone System
- local utilities (e.g., hydro, gas, water)
- local branches of voluntary organizations
4.5 Provincial response levels
4.5.1 The provincial response level adopted depends on the notification category received from BNGS (see Table 4.2).
4.5.2 Reportable event and abnormal incident
- In the event of a Reportable Event notification from BNGS the provincial response level adopted should be Routine Monitoring, unless the PEOC Commander decides otherwise.
- In the event of an Abnormal Incident notification from BNGS, the provincial response level adopted should be Enhanced Monitoring, unless the PEOC Commander decides otherwise.
- In these cases, the notifications and level of staffing shall proceed according to Table 4.2, unless the PEOC Commander decides otherwise.
- The PEOC Commander shall ensure the applicable stakeholders are notified when a response to a Reportable Event or Abnormal Incident has been terminated.
4.5.3 On-site emergency
An On-site Emergency can result in either a partial or full activation provincial response (see Figure 4.1), depending on the source of the accident and the prospects for the resulting emission:
- An On-site Emergency with no emission occurring shall normally result in a partial activation response.
- An On-site Emergency with a (non-reactor) emission occurring or expected within 12 hours shall normally result in a full activation response.
4.5.4 General emergency
A General Emergency notification from BNGS shall result in a full activation response (see Figure 4.2) as it denotes an emission from a reactor can result due to fuel and containment failures.
4.5.5 The remainder of this chapter therefore deals with the operational response to an accident at BNGS which results in, or has the potential to result in, an emission of radioactive material to the atmosphere, and therefore requires a partial or full activation response.
4.5.6 The partial and full activation response to a nuclear emergency is described below in relation to the three successive phases defined by the PNERP Master Plan, Section 5.9.
Figure 4.1: Initial provincial response to an on site emergency notification
Note: Some actions may be implemented simultaneously, although they are shown here sequentially.
- On-site Emergency Notification
- Notification Category Detail:
Ongoing or Imminent (non-reactor) Emission- Provincial Response Level:
Full Activation - Initiate Public Alerting and Issue Emergency Bulletin to Shelter AAZ and Evacuate Lake Sector P23
- Consider Declaration of a Provincial Emergency
- PEOC Considers Other Precautionary and Protective Measures
- Issue Emergency Bulletin for Other Protective Measures and Ingestion Control Measures (as appropriate)
- Provincial Response Level:
- Notification Category Detail:
Delayed Emission (more than 12 hours)- Provincial Response Level:
Partial Activation - Consider Venting Options
- Full Activation
- Consideration of a Provincial Emergency Declaration
- PEOC considers Precautionary and Protective Measures (as appropriate)
- Initate Public Alerting and Issue Emergency Bulletin for Precautionary and Protective Measures and Ingesion Control Measures (as appropriate)
- Provincial Response Level:
- Notification Category Detail:
Download printer-friendly version of Figure 4.1 (PNG, 69 KB).
Figure 4.2: Initial provincial response to a general emergency notification
Note: Some actions may be implemented simultaneously, although they are shown here sequentially.
- General Emergency Notification
- Ongoing or Imminent (reactor) Emission (12 hours or less)
- Provincial Response Level:
Full Activation - Initiate Public Alerting and Issue Emergency Bulletin to Evacuate AAZ including all Lake Sectors and Shelter remainder of DPZ
- PEOC Considers Other Precautionary and Protective Measures
- Issue Emergency Bulletin for Other Protective Measures and Ingestion Control Measures (as appropriate)
- Provincial Response Level:
- Ongoing or Imminent (reactor) Emission (12 hours or less)
Download printer-friendly version of Figure 4.2 (PNG, 37 KB).
4.6 Early phase response
4.6.1 The early phase:
- Begins with an initial notification of an emergency prior to, or during a radioactive release.
- Lasts anywhere from hours to days and in the event of, an ongoing or imminent emission, should involve the implementation of automatic default protective measures (see Table 4.3).
- Ends when the radioactive release is brought under control and reliable environmental radiation monitoring is available to be used for protective action decision-making.
- Shall be terminated and the intermediate phase shall begin based on the criteria in Section 4.7 below.
4.6.2 The operational response in this phase differs depending on whether the initial provincial response level is partial or full activation.
4.6.3 Partial activation
- A PEOC partial activation response (see Figure 4.1) is adopted when it is expected that a radioactive release will occur at some point in the future and therefore protective or operational measures (other than monitoring and assessment of the situation) are not likely to be required within 36 hours.
- When the PEOC is partially activated, initial actions include:
- Notification of the emergency management organization and set up and full staffing of the PEOC and the Municipal EOCs to monitor and assess the situation on a continuous basis.
- Activation of the Ministry EOCs and Unified Transportation Coordination Centre and staffing as appropriate to the situation.
- Activation of the Emergency Information Centres (EICs) with staffing at an appropriate level. Provincial staff to be dispatched, as appropriate.
- All emergency response personnel not immediately required should be placed on standby. This provision should ensure that personnel can be quickly contacted when needed to report to their duty stations.
- Other emergency centres should be readied to a level where they can become fully operational without undue delay, when required. Specific levels of readiness shall be described in the municipal plans.
- Consideration shall be given to issuing an emergency bulletin(s) and news release(s).
- Technical assessments of the accident situation and projected radiation doses shall be carried out on a regular basis by the PEOC Scientific Section, as described in Section 4.6.5 below.
- The technical assessments carried out by the PEOC Scientific Section, as well as inputs from the other PEOC sections shall be compiled by the PEOC Planning Section Chief into recommendations for protective action decision-making, to the PEOC Commander.
- The PEOC Commander, in consultation with the PEOC Command Section and select stakeholder organizations (including MOHLTC, Designated Municipalities and others deemed appropriate), shall consider and decide on the need for operational measures as well as future protective actions and ensure that all stakeholders are so informed.
- If the emergency situation is resolved and the potential for off-site consequences is eliminated, the PEOC Commander shall downgrade the provincial response level, as appropriate.
- Alternatively, the PEOC Commander shall upgrade the response level to full activation when a radioactive emission seems likely to occur in 36 hours or less or, as deemed appropriate.
4.6.4 Full activation
- A PEOC full activation response should be adopted as a result of:
- An initial notification from BNGS stating that an emission is ongoing or imminent (On-site or General Emergency), or
- An escalation of an existing emergency situation, where an emission is now expected in 36 hours or less
- The following actions shall be initiated upon adoption of a full activation response:
- All emergency operations centres, Emergency Information Centres, Reception Centres, Evacuation Centres, Emergency Worker Centres and Monitoring and Decontamination Units are fully staffed and operational.
- All emergency response personnel from Paragraph i. above immediately report to their places of duty.
- Public alerting is initiated and emergency bulletins issued concurrently (see Sections 6.2 and 6.4).
- Operational directives (or emergency orders) issued for protective actions per c) or d) below, as appropriate.
- PEOC Commander advises government of the need for a provincial emergency declaration (see PNERP Master Plan Section 1.5.1).
- Provincial Chief Emergency Information Officer (PCEIO) shall consider establishing a Joint Information Centre as necessary (see Paragraph 6.5.2 e)).
- Where the full activation response level is adopted as a result of an initial notification from BNGS that an emission is ongoing or imminent (see Paragraph (a) (i) above), the default actions noted in Table 4.3 shall be implemented, unless there are good reasons for modifying the response. This default response is undertaken due to the potential lack of detailed information or plant data together with a lack of available time for analysis.
- Where an escalating event results in the upgrade to a full activation response (see Paragraph (a) (ii) above), data gathering and analysis are already being undertaken by the emergency response organization, with a protective action decision-making process in place. Therefore, in this escalating type of scenario, the technical and operational assessments and the recommendation process (see Section 4.6.5 below) replaces the need for default actions.
4.6.5 PEOC Scientific Section technical assessments
In the early phase, prior to or during a radioactive emission, the PEOC Scientific Section shall undertake technical assessments in accordance with PEOC Scientific Section procedures which shall serve as input into the PEOC Planning Section recommendations for Command decision-making. Examples of technical assessments include:
- Accident assessments
The Nuclear Incident Group (NIG) of the PEOC Scientific Section shall receive hourly plant status and data from the BNGS EOC, through agreed to transmission systems (and backup), and shall on an ongoing basis:
- Evaluate the status of relevant station systems and make ongoing assessments of possible accident progressions, considering both positive and negative outcomes (see paragraph ii below).
- Monitor the progress of station vacuum structure repressurization and continually forecast the date and time when its pressure could reach, firstly, the minimum level required for the Filtered Air Discharge System (FADS) operation and, secondly, the level at which FADS operation becomes necessary.
- Analyze venting data and make projections to inform venting decision-making by the PEOC Commander and stakeholders (see Section 4.6.6 below).
- Liaise with EMC staff and undertake a technical projection of the maximum distance from the reactor facility at which the generic criteria (see PNERP Master Plan, Annex E, Appendix 1) for protective measures against the plume are likely to be reached during the anticipated duration of the emission (allowance should be made for the effects of early venting, if applicable):
- evacuation
- sheltering-in-place
- iodine thyroid blocking
- Condition of station systems
- Table 4.3 describes four main categories for the condition of station systems along with some examples of each. It can provide a baseline for making appropriate judgements or, if time and adequate information are not available, it may be used to determine default measures.
- In an actual event, the estimate of station conditions may not conform exactly to the various sets of conditions given in Table 4.3. In such a case, the default protective measures listed in the table, may be appropriately modified.
- The PEOC Scientific Section Chief shall determine and make recommendations to the PEOC Commander for approval on:
- the set of protective measures that best match the current conditions
- whether current meteorological conditions warrant any change to the distance out to which protective measures are advised
- the DPZ and CPZ response sectors likely to be affected by the emission
- Exposure levels
The PEOC Scientific Section shall make an assessment as to whether the dose in any sector(s) is likely to require the activation of the Radiation Health Response Plan (see Paragraph 6.9.6).
- Subsequent technical assessments
As more data and projections become available, the PEOC Scientific Section shall continuously update the assessments made in order to establish whether any additional protective measures are required.
- During a Design Basis Accident (DBA), the holdup period of any radioactive material within the station containment structure (e.g., vacuum building) permits the venting of said contained radioactivity in a controlled manner and in a safe direction, i.e., over the lake (refer to PNERP Master Plan, Annex G).
- During a Beyond Design Basis Accident (BDBA), the holdup period of any radioactive material may be significantly reduced and radioactive material may be released in an uncontrolled manner. BDBAs are categorized as General Emergencies and as such the PEOC assumes full activation as described in Section 4.6.4 above.
- For all accidents, the PEOC Commander may decide at any time to upgrade to full activation as conditions warrant however the Commander should upgrade no later than 36 hours prior to venting.
- For all accidents, the BNGS operator shall include, in each hourly report to the PEOC, an estimate of the time at which the vacuum building pressure would reach the minimum level at which a venting system can be operated.
- The time interval between the occurrence of the accident and containment pressure reaching this minimum level may depend on the condition and behaviour of the containment system. With no impairment to containment, this time interval is expected to be about 2 ½ days (an impaired containment could significantly reduce that time).
- For all accidents, the BNGS operator shall consult with the Province, Designated Municipalities and CNSC before undertaking any venting activity, unless venting must be performed in an urgent manner to protect the structural integrity of containment (see Paragraph 2.6.4 b)). In such a case, every effort shall be made to inform these stakeholders as early as possible.
- The PEOC Commander should consider, in consultation with the BNGS operator, the CNSC, and Municipality of Kincardine, whether venting over Lake Huron (according to the considerations in the PNERP Master Plan, Annex G), would be feasible and advisable. Detailed procedures for such decision-making should be developed in consultation with the above agencies and incorporated in the PEOC procedures for the PEOC Scientific, Operations and Command Sections, as appropriate.
- Environmental Radiation Monitoring
If venting over Lake Huron, ground monitoring teams from BNGS shall complete radiological surveys following the shoreline, out to 20 km on either side of the plant to detect any "blow back" of radioactivity towards land during venting. Any radioactivity detected shall be immediately reported by the BNGS operator to the PEOC.
4.6.7 Early phase protective action decision-making
- The PEOC Scientific Section's technical assessment of the situation should produce a projection of the maximum distance from BNGS at which the generic criteria for evacuation, sheltering-in-place and KI ingestion are likely to be reached during the anticipated duration of the emission.
- The PEOC Planning Section shall undertake an evaluation of this technical assessment, taking into account operational and public policy considerations, and shall prepare a preliminary assessment regarding the need to implement these measures, proposed timings, and the area within which these measures should be taken.
- These assessments shall be continually updated and, as soon as a reasonably certain picture of the evacuation (and other protective measures) distance is achieved, the PEOC, through the Command Section, shall consult with applicable stakeholders (Designated Municipalities, host and support Municipalities, federal departments, the reactor facility).
- Command decisions on protective action shall be communicated to the emergency response organization (see PEOC Command Section procedures) and the applicable emergency bulletin(s) shall be issued (per PEOC Operations Section procedures).
4.7 Intermediate phase response
4.7.1 The intermediate phase begins once the radioactive release has been brought under control and reliable environmental radiation monitoring is available for use in protective action decision-making.
4.7.2 Following the radioactive emission, the PEOC Scientific Section's input into the protective action decision-making process shall no longer be based on modelling the projected doses or on default measures but rather on the tangible results of environmental radiation monitoring.
4.7.3 The PEOC Scientific Section shall undertake, and continuously update, the following assessments:/p>
- Off-site environmental radiation monitoring undertaken by the ERAMG shall produce a picture of the contamination situation.
- The PEOC Scientific Section Chief shall make technical recommendations for protective action (exposure and ingestion control measures) based on the results of the actual contamination levels as compared against the Operational Intervention Levels (OILs) (per the PNERP Master Plan, Annex E, Appendix 2).
- The PEOC Scientific Section Chief shall make recommendations regarding sector safety status on behalf of emergency workers operating in the area.
- The intermediate phase operations of the PEOC Scientific Section shall be detailed in the Scientific Section procedures.
4.7.4 Intermediate phase protective action decision-making
- The PEOC Planning Section shall undertake an assessment of these Scientific Section technical recommendations, in light of operational and public policy considerations, and shall prepare recommendations for the PEOC Commander regarding the protective measures, areas where they should be implemented, and implementation timings.
- These assessments shall be continually updated and, as soon as a reasonably certain picture of the evacuation (and other protective measures) distance is achieved, the PEOC Commander shall advise all stakeholders of the protective action strategy to be undertaken. If time is available, the PEOC Commander shall undertake prior consultation with applicable stakeholders on the protective action strategy recommendations.
- Planning for the management of radioactive waste (see Section 6.11) generated by the emergency should preferably begin during the intermediate phase.
4.8 Transition to the recovery phase
4.8.1 During the recovery phase actions will commence to restore the affected area to pre-emergency conditions and to scale back the emergency response organization.
4.8.2 As there may not be a clear distinction between phases, with emergency response operations occurring in all three, planning for recovery should begin as soon as practical.
4.8.3 Stakeholder recovery plans should include measures to address the following as applicable to their organization:
- recovery organization structure
- care for persons exposed or contaminated
- long-term relocation
- resettlement and return of evacuees
- long-term support for those living in contaminated areas
- decontamination and reconstruction of property damaged during the emergency
- economic impact issues and improvement plans
4.8.4 Stakeholder recovery plans should be prepared in advance and conform to the provincial recovery plan.
Table 4.1: Initial notification categories and criteria
Category | Criteria (alternative) | Examples |
---|---|---|
Reportable event |
|
1A. Level 1 or 2 impairment of a special safety system, which persists for more than 4 hours. 1B. Entry into emergency operating procedures. 2. Reduced ability to:
3A. Equipment failure. 3B. Extreme environmental conditions. 3C. Earthquake. 3D. Fire or explosion. 4A. Unexpected or unplanned activation of the ECI system component that does not result in injection. 4B. Unexpected or unplanned activation of the containment system. 4C. Excludes events initiated during testing. 5. As per nuclear emergency procedures. 6A. A publicized bomb threat. 6B. A breach or attempted breach of the protected area. |
Abnormal incident |
|
1. LOCA on one or more units, without fuel failures and with or without containment impairment. 2. Similar causes as for # 3 under Reportable Event 3A. Activation of the ECI system component that results in injection. 3B. Activation of the containment system on high activity or pressure. |
On-site emergency (Note: A notification with this category must state whether an emission is ongoing or, if not, give a best estimate of when it is expected to commence). |
|
1A. LOCA with fuel failures on one or more units. 1B. Fuelling machine accident. 2. Spent fuel bay accident. 3A. Loss of all AC power. 3B. Extreme environmental conditions. 3C. Earthquake damage. 3D. Fire or explosion. 3E. Entry requirements met for SAMG or EME to maintain fuel cooling. |
General emergency (Note: A notification with this category must state whether an emission is ongoing or, if not, give a best estimate of when it is expected to commence). |
|
|
* To be defined in reactor facility procedures.
Table 4.2: Initial provincial and municipal response
Initial notification | Initial provincial response | Initial municipal response |
---|---|---|
Reportable event |
Routine monitoring
|
Emergency response staff remain in contact with the PEOC, and monitor event. |
Abnormal incident |
Enhanced monitoring
|
Emergency response staff monitor event, preferably from Municipal Emergency Operations Centres (EOCs). |
On-site emergency (No emission occurring) |
Partial activation
|
|
On-site emergency (Emission Ongoing or expected within 12 hours) |
Full activation
|
|
General emergency (Emission ongoing or expected within 12 hours) |
Full activation
|
|
Table 4.3: Default protective measures
Condition of station systems | Examples | Default protective measures Issue immediate operational directives |
---|---|---|
A. Intermediate to severe core damage with an accompanying loss of the containment function. |
Either:
Combined with either:
|
|
B. Intermediate level of core damage and a loss of the filtered pathway. |
Either:
Combined with either:
|
|
C. Intermediate to severe fuel damage with containment envelope impairment leading to early venting. |
Either:
Combined with: A loss of containment pressure control requiring early venting. |
|
D. All other events or conditions likely to lead to an emission. |
Spent fuel bay accident. |
|